Peer Review as a Dialogue: Transforming Critique into Contribution

Staged by the BAM Peer Review College (PRC)

Untitled-79 (2)b.jpg

Description

This workshop builds on the previous online BAM Peer Review College event “Surviving the Peer Review Process”. While that webinar emphasised emotional resilience and coping strategies, this In-Person event at Durham University Business School, deliberately serves a dual purpose:

  1. enhancing participants’ ability to conduct high-quality developmental reviews through targeted input from experienced academics, and
  2. strengthening their skill in working constructively and effectively with reviewer feedback in relation to their own manuscripts.

This programme is presented in four stages:
 

Stage 1: Virtual kick-off
Date
: Thursday 19th February 2026, 14:30 - 15:30 GMT

An online Teams session (1-hour) introducing the goals of the programme.
The Teams link for this event will be sent on the morning and 1 hour before the virtual event.

Activities will include:

  • Scene-setting
  • Virtual meet-and-greet session, including clarification regarding aims and structure
  • Clarifying the workshop’s dual focus on (a) improving participants’ reviewing skills and (b) strengthening their approaches to responding to reviewer feedback.

Stage 2: Submission and allocation of pre-workshop reviewing task
Date
: Thursday 12th March 2026

  • Participants will submit an extended abstract of their working paper, and a peer taking part in the workshop and an external academic will provide feedback.
  • Participants will act as a peer reviewer for the extended abstract of another delegate and submit their response to the organisers within 1 week.
  • The developmental review participants produce will be used in the sessions dedicated to reviewing practice and will serve as the basis for reflection on reviewing styles, tone, and structure.

Stage 3: Submission of response file (2 weeks before Durham)
Date: Thursday 2nd April 2026

Participants will receive feedback on their extended abstract. Based on the feedback, they devise a revision plan and a response to the reviewers’ recommendations.

  • Participants should bring both documents to the in-person workshop.
  • These documents will be used in the interactive sessions on responding to reviewer comments.

Stage 4: In-person workshop (Durham)
Date: Thursday 16th April 2026, 11:00 BST – Friday 17th April 2026, 15:00 BST

Please see the provisional agenda for the day HERE


Provider Information

Staged by the BAM Peer Review College (PRC), in partnership with Durham University Business School.


Who Should Attend?

Late-stage PhD candidates, and early and mid-career scholars, who:

  • Are seeking reflective input in their own revision practices for journal paper R&R decisions,
  • Are seeking to get involved in peer-reviewing for journals in the broader business and management domain,
  • Are interested in hearing and learning from reviewing practices of more senior colleagues, to advance their own academic reviewing service in terms of conceptualisation, structure and writing.

The event speaks to Sections A1, C1 and E1, as detailed in the BAM Framework 


Submission

Submissions

Submission and allocation of pre-workshop reviewing task
Deadline
: Thursday 12th March 2026

  • Participants will submit an extended abstract of their working paper, and a peer taking part in the workshop and an external academic will provide feedback.
  • Participants will act as a peer reviewer for the extended abstract of another delegate and submit their response to the organisers within 1 week.
  • The developmental review participants produce will be used in the sessions dedicated to reviewing practice and will serve as the basis for reflection on reviewing styles, tone, and structure.

These submissions can be sent to Prof Rudolf R Sinkovics at the link here [COMING SOON]


Submission of response file (2 weeks before In-Person Durham Workshop)
Deadline: Thursday 2nd April 2026

Participants will receive feedback on their extended abstract. Based on the feedback, they devise a revision plan and a response to the reviewers’ recommendations.

  • Participants should bring both documents to the in-person workshop.
  • These documents will be used in the interactive sessions on responding to reviewer comments.
Guest Speakers
Prof Stewart Miller

Prof Stewart Miller

Professor of Strategy and International Business, Durham University

Prof Anna Morgan-Thomas

Prof Anna Morgan-Thomas

Professor of Digital Management and Innovation, University of Glasgow

Prof Stefanie Reissner

Prof Stefanie Reissner

Professor of Organization Studies, Durham University

Prof Noemi Sinkovics

Prof Noemi Sinkovics

Professor of Sustainable and Responsible Business , Newcastle University

Prof Rudolf Sinkovics

Prof Rudolf Sinkovics

Professor of Strategy and International Business, Durham University

Professor Martin Spring

Professor Martin Spring

Professor of Operations Management, Lancaster University

 
Benefits of Attendance

Benefits of attending 

  • Learning and improving ability to conduct constructive, field-sensitive developmental reviews of peers’ work.
  • Identifying key revision priorirites through analysis and synthesis of reviewer comments.
  • Mapping of reviewer comments to specific revision actions.
  • Ability to draft persuasive and professional response-to-reviewer letters.
  • Ability to work confidently across qualitative and quantitative traditions when reviewing or responding to methodological critique.
Venue

Venue

Durham University Business School,
The Waterside Building,
Riverside Place,
Durham,
DH1 1SL

FIND US HERE

Event Fees

Event Fees

BAM Member: £45
BAM Student Member: £30
BAM Non-Member: £135

If you are booking multiple paid events as a Non-Member, it may be cheaper for you to purchase a BAM Membership as nearly all BAM Events are free or at a discounted rate for Members.

For more information, please visit BAM Membership

Registration Deadline: Wednesday 18th February 2026, 23:59 BST

Contact
Prof Rudolf Sinkovics

Prof Rudolf Sinkovics

Professor of Strategy and International Business, Durham University

Prof Stefanie Reissner

Prof Stefanie Reissner

Professor of Organization Studies, Durham University

 

 

Payment and Cancellation Policy

Payment for the event must be received before the start date of the event concerned. Access will not be permitted to the event if full payment has not been received. 

Cancellations 

  • Cancellations received within 14 days of booking your place on the event will receive a full refund. 

  • Cancellations received after the 14-day cancellation period and later than 14 days before the start date of the event will not be eligible for a refund.  

  • Although we endeavour to run all events as advertised, BAM reserves the right to cancel any event if, for example, there are not enough people to justify running the event or if other significant unforeseen circumstances arise.

To cancel a booking a cancellation request must be submitted via your BAM Account, to do this:

  • Go to your BAM Account
  • Click 'My Events'
  • Under 'Upcoming Events' will be the booking, please click Cancel Booking
  • Follow the steps and complete the request